Tuesday, June 9, 2009
Harper's Island: Examining The Remaining Suspects
HENRY DUNN
Evidence: He doesn't have strong alibis for any of the murders (there is a time issue with one murder, but I'm going to assume time progression from scene to scene is not necessarily in "real time")
Motive: We know his parents are dead - but we have no further details. There could be motive in this somewhere. BUT, I think no matter who the killer is, it ties to Wakefield somehow. So maybe Henry is Wakefield's child. Maybe Henry and Abby are half-siblings - since it's been said that the killings are "all about Abby".
Arguments: Message boards are on fire with people naming Henry as the killer. AND the most recent episode made him look a bit guilty...That makes me feel like the writers WANT us to think the killer is Henry, which would mean it's NOT.
My verdict: One of my main suspects!
TRISH WELLINGTON
Evidence: None that I've picked up on.
Motive: Nothing so far.
Arguments: She was shown in the company of others in the most recent episode - when at least 2 murders took place
My verdict: Not the killer.
JIMMY MANCE
Evidence: He has the tools, the strength, and - for awhile - the opportunity to commit the murders
Motive: All I can come up with is revenge for Abby leaving without a goodbye 7 years earlier - and that's not much of a motive at all
Arguments: He was with Abby when the murder of Cole Harkin took place. So, unless that was somehow rigged (like Hunter Jennings and Mr. Wellington), he couldn't be the killer.
My verdict: Probably not the killer.
MAGGIE KRELL
Evidence: A lot of screenshots of Candlewick Inn stuff...The matchbox for Lucy's death was from the Inn...The boat for Hunter's death was from the Inn. She sent Abby to turn off the lights, which set off the head spade for Mr. W's death. AND - possible clue - in the most recent ep, the word Boniface was shown, which means "keeper of an inn" - and that's Maggie!
Motive: None so far, but I would assume a connection to Wakefield.
Arguments: I have a hard time believing a woman could carry out some of the murders - ones that require great, great strength. And Maggie has been such a background character - it would kind of be a letdown for her to be the killer. We'll see if she's featured more in upcoming eps.
My verdict: Very possible. One of my 3 top suspects.
BETH BARRINGTON
Evidence: None that I've found.
Motive: None so far.
Arguments: Like I said before, I'm not convinced a woman would have the strenght to carry out some of the murders.
My verdict: Nope. Not the killer.
CAL VANDEUSEN
Evidence: Young Madison made references to a "new friend" who was telling her creepy things about the island - and we know Cal got along well w/Madison on the boat trip to the island. Also, as a doctor, Cal has a little more knowledge about the human body - which couldn't hurt. And, we were shown a semi-violent side of him for about 5seconds in episode 1.
Motive: None so far.
Arguments: Cal has been shown as a pretty passive guy. His personality doesn't fit the profile of a murderer. Plus, for 2 murders in ep 2, he was hanging upside down from a tree. Pretty solid alibi.
My verdict: No. I think Cal's a good guy.
CHLOE CARTER
Evidence: She has a fascination with serial killers and knows a lot about Wakefield.
Motive: None so far.
Arguments: She's a girl - and not a particularly strong one - so I say she absolutely could not have hacked up Uncle Marty - or hoisted Richard onto the tree. Plus, she has alibis for a few of the murders.
My verdict: No.
SULLY
Evidence: None that I've found.
Motive: None indicated so far.
Arguments: Has alibis for a few of the murders.
My verdict: No.
DANNY BROOKS
Evidence: Nope.
Motive: Nope.
Arguments: Seems to have alibis for a couple of the murders.
My verdict: My gut says NO.
KATHERINE WELLINGTON
Evidence: Not really.
Motive: I'd guess money, if anything.
Arguments: In the most recent ep, she was with a group while murders were taking place.
My verdict: Doubtful.
NIKKI BOLTON
Evidence: None that I've found.
Motive: Nothing comes to mind.
Arguments: Hard to say for sure, but I think she has an alibi for the reverend's murder (being at The Cannery as part of the scavenger hunt)...also, she discovered Kelly's body.
My verdict: Doubtful.
SHANE PIERCE
Evidence: Doesn't matter.
Motive: Doesn't matter.
Arguments: He was in jail for several of the murders. Even witnessed one.
My verdict: No.
SHEA ALLEN
Evidence: Nothing I've picked up on.
Motive: No clear possible motive.
Arguments: In the most recent ep, she was shown with group when murders took place.
My verdict: No.
SHERIFF MILLS
Evidence: He has a virtual shrine to the Wakefield murders in his home.
Motive: Wakefield-related
Arguments: In the most recent ep, he was in Cole Harkin's cabin when Cole was killed with arrows. Unless the arrows were rigged, he couldn't have done it.
My verdict: Don't think so.
ABBY MILLS
Evidence: I'm not sold on any.
Motive: Her mom was killed 7 years ago - maybe that drove her crazy.
Arguments: She has alibis for several of the murders.
My verdict: Not a chance, in my opinion.
MADISON ALLEN
Evidence: She's creepy and seems to know things.
Motive: No?
Arguments: She's a 9 year old kid.
My verdict: No way.
JD DUNN
IS he dead? It wasn't clear.
Evidence: Plenty of evidence. He's been in fights, put a dead deer on Shane's truck (and maybe a deer head in Henry's tub), messed around with fireworks as a prank...Was the last person to see Kelly before she died...and had dead Uncle Marty's phone in his possession.
Motive: Craziness, possible Wakefield link.
Arguments: He was in jail during...what? 2 killings? He's the obvious red herring.
My verdict: No. And I hope he's not dead.
AND
JOEL BOOTH
Evidence: I know he's "dead" - but his death could have been easily faked. Going into this show, I said I expected the killer to fake their death partway through. So I can't help but be suspicious of this one.
Motive: Likely Wakefield related. Literally. I think he could be related to Wakefield. Or just crazy.
Arguments: He's presumed dead. I think I read on a message board that the producers/writers/something confirmed that he's dead (I haven't seen a direct quote myself, though)
My verdict: One of my main suspects!
Monday, June 1, 2009
Harper's Island: 5 Most Suspicious Suspects Countdown

- From what I can tell, he has been pretty much "available" for all the murders...
He's from Tacoma - just like the previous serial killer on the island - coincidence, or something more?
His parents died. But how? We haven't been given much explanation there. Mighty peculiar, eh?
His brother is the red herring. Nice way to deflect suspicion, I think. Make JD seem like the bad brother, Henry the good brother. But in reality, it's the opposite. (Elaborating on this, I think he could've swiped Uncle Marty's cell and planted it in JD's stuff. Not a lot of brotherly love here.)
And if they really want to fool us, why not have the nice guy be the killer?
Monday, May 18, 2009
Season Finales...
THE OFFICE
Thursday, May 14
Good episode...but not season finale worthy. First of all, in previous seasons, we've gotten a super-sized finale. This one was only the standard half hour. And the so-called "cliffhanger"...extremely underwhelming. It would've been SO much better if Angela would've been pregnant. There would've been an awesome "who's the father?" cliffhanger. And having Michael see the girl from the Blood Drive episode at the end would've been great, too. Instead, all we get is...really nothing. Nothing to look forward to for next season. Of course I'll watch it, but I won't be combing message boards over the summer looking for inside info or anything. Yawn. MY GRADE: As an episode, I'd give it a B, maybe B+, but as a season finale, I expect more, so it gets a C.
GREY'S ANATOMY
Thursday, May 14
I will admit, I've barely watched this season. I started it off, missed some eps, and then accumulated about 6 hours worth on my dvr...all of which I watched yesterday - and only because my mom said she just HAD to discuss the finale with me. Honestly, I was considering deleting the eps unwatched to clear up dvr space...but I am really glad I didn't! I was blown away with the George thing. Absolutely blown away. My husband (who does not watch the show, but happened to be in the room on his computer as I watched) even had to comment on the brilliance. Kudos to the writers because THAT is how a finale should be done. MY GRADE: A+
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER
Monday, May 18
Not bad, could've been better. The episode was actually quite good - and I think it DID set up for some interesting things next season (assuming there is one) - but there was no big cliffhanger moment - which I think all season finales should have. However, it is tricky with this show, since this could very well have been the SERIES finale. And a cliffhanger for a SERIES finale is rather frustrating. So they did a fair job making an episode that could go either way. MY GRADE: B-
THE MENTALIST
Tuesday, May 19
Well...I'm glad that the Red John story will live on, but there were some very big leaps made on this episode. "I knew you were the killer because you were chewing gum!" But, it IS just a tv show, so I can try to overlook that...Still, I expect more from a season finale. I want a cliffhanger, darn it! I want something to look forward to next season - something to wonder about through the summer. Even something small. Based on that, this show didn't deliver. In fact, the episode itself was a bit on the dull side. MY GRADE: C+
90210
Tuesday, May 19
Wow, so much happened in this finale episode! It was a strong ep (for what it is), with focus on all the major characters - and every storyline left off with questions to be answered next season. Which I love. That's exactly what I want in a finale - a whirlwind of activity and a good cliffhanger. Even if it involves my least favorite character, Annie...Oh, and the parents eating the pot brownies was one of the best moments on the series ever! Well done, but I do subtract points for the heavily contrived Jen/Liam storyline - seemed a little too thrown together to me. And the Brenda dream...I think the writers were eating pot brownies on that one. MY GRADE: A-
.
Sunday, April 5, 2009
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
5 BEST SHOWS CURRENTLY ON TV - ACCORDING TO ME
#4

Wednesday, October 29, 2008
JUMPING THE SHARK...
In the world of television, this term is used to pinpoint the moment that a particular show dropped off in quality - beyond repair.
There is a webiste and everything.
I'm taking all of my favorite shows and then some - I'll tell you the majority opinion (according to www.jumptheshark.com) as well as my own. Feel free to comment - tell if you agree or disagree!
GILMORE GIRLS
Majority opinion: When Lorelai slept w/Christopher
My opinion: Rory steals a yacht and drops out of Yale...Rory would not do that. And it set into motion a whole chain of events that were - for lack of a better word - sucky. The show did not need to go there.
VERONICA MARS
Majority opinion: Never jumped!
My opinion: Never jumped! (I didn't care for the 3rd season as much, but it was still quality - and didn't ruin the show beyond repair)
GREY'S ANATOMY
Majority opinion: Meredith died in the ferry crash
My opinion: Meredith slept with George (Why does everyone want to sleep with George? I don't get it. First Meredith, then Callie, then Izzie, now Lexie. And it's too much of a plot point. I don't like it.)
DAWSON'S CREEK
Majority opinion: Graduation
My opinion: I don't know, I've never watched it
BEVERLY HILLS 90210
Majority opinion: Brenda's departure
My opinion: Brenda's departure...Everything shifted after that and it became a soap opera. It was no longer the show I loved.
SEINFELD
Majority opinion: Never jumped
My opinion: Never jumped - in fact, some of the best episodes (in my opinion) were in the final season. And I LOVED the finale.
FRIENDS
Majority opinion: Never jumped
My opinion: the romance between Rachel and Joey - although, there was some really crappy stuff done w/various characters before that...but the Rachel/Joey episodes are unwatchable for me. Yuck.
BLOSSOM
Majority opinion: "a very special" (in other words, when the plotlines began getting too serious and movie-of-the-weekish
My opinion: Never jumped. Personally, I liked the "very special" episodes of Blossom. It was a good show. Why is this show not in syndication?!?!
GROWING PAINS
Majority opinion: the birth of Chrissy
My opinion: the rapid aging of Chrissy (she went from baby to age 7 just "like that") and, with that, the great dynamic the Seavers had shared over the years was changed.
KATE AND ALLIE
Majority opinion: Allie marries Bob
My opinion: My first instinct is to say "never jumped", because there are really good episodes all the way to the end. However, I do admit, the last season was not quite up to par. And, while it was the same time as Allie married Bob, that wasn't the problem. The problem was Kate. During the final season, her character changed. She suddenly seemed less secure and strong and spunky, as she had been throughout the rest of the series. So, I guess my answer here would be "Kate changed" or "season 5" - but not attributed to the marriage of Allie and Bob or the move to midtown.
DHARMA AND GREG
Majority opinion: the car accident
My opinion: the car accident (though I hated the storyline involving Charlie the college professor who fell for Dharma - that sucked)
PARTY OF FIVE
Majority opinion: too much tragedy (wow, that's non-specific...)
My opinion: day one. I hate that show.
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER
Majority opinion: Never jumped
My opinion: Don't know - I've never watched it
Thursday, October 9, 2008
TOP 10 LIST OF THE DAY...
#10
#9
#8
#7
#6
#5
#4
#3
#2
#1
Tuesday, September 30, 2008
#1: "NOBODY LIKES A BLONDE IN A HAMSTER BALL..."
In a word, Veronica Mars = dichotomy.

WHO IS VERONICA MARS?
(from the dvd)
Monday, September 29, 2008
#2: "PEOPLE WHO HAVE MONEY DON'T NEED PEOPLE."

of Family Ties
I wrote a really great post about Alex. And then my cat jumped on my keyboard and erased it all...and for some reason, blogger hadn't saved it. So, if this blog posting doesn't do Alex P. Keaton justice, I assure you the previous, cat sabotaged one did.
And then there was Alex.
He was certainly not a typical teen. He carried a briefcase. He read the Wall Street Journal. Watched Wall Street Week. He idolized not a rock star or movie star, but Presidents Ronald Reagan and Richard Nixon. All of this to the chagrin of his former hippie parents.
A GREAT ALEX EPISODE:
Sunday, September 28, 2008
#3: "I THINK YOU SHOULD TELL THEM TO TAKE THEIR INVITATION, FOLD IT IN FIVE CORNERS, AND STICK IT WHERE THE SUN DON'T SHINE!"
If I could be any TV character for a day, this might be the one. Just for the speeches - the perfectly worded, rapid-fire, giving the world a piece of her mind speeches.Julia Sugarbaker, in my opinion, is one of the most well-crafted women ever on the small screen. Because of the speeches :-)
Kudos to the writers for crafting these wonderful works of word art - and kudos to Dixie Carter for performing them to perfection!
And, by the way, her nickname is "the Terminator".
REESE: Oh yeah? That's what you think about men? Well let me tell you something about women............... They're always late.
Julia gets a visit in jail from the female publisher of a nudie magazine.
TERRY: I've decided to drop the lawsuit.
JULIA: Yes, they told me that, too.
TERRY: I had you checked out. You're a very tough lady. And I like that.
JULIA: So you're graciously going to set me free?
TERRY: Just so you know Mrs. Sugarbaker, this is still America, and free speech will always be protected.
JULIA: I know it will. But pornography won't always be, Miss Wilder. This country will let the Nazis speak, and the Ku Klux Klansmen speak because as dispicable as their statements are, they are speaking their mind. But when you publish your magazine, you're not speaking your mind. You'd shut that magazine down tomorrow if it weren't turning a profit. You know it and I know it. Pornography is not free speech, it's commerce. Otherwise you couldn't zone it out of certain nice areas of the city.
TERRY: Well, I see I am getting nowhere. We're both business women. Let's just leave it at that. I won't bother you, and you won't bother me.
JULIA: No, that's not quite right, Miss Wilder. You bother me very much. I know I can be sanctimonious and self-righteous, but nevertheless I've just gotta say it. Shame on you for calling yourself a feminist. And shame on you for hurting and demeaning women everywhere -- all for a lousy nickel. I may not be able to stop you today, but someday...we're going zone you right out of the city. And then we're gonna zone you right out of the county and then we're going to zone you right out of the country. And in fact, Miss Wilder, if I had my way, we might just zone you right off the globe.
Saturday, September 27, 2008
#4:IT'S WONDERFUL DATING IN MIAMI. EVERY SINGLE MAN UNDER 80 SELLS COCAINE."

Some great Dorothy moments:
Friday, September 26, 2008
#5: "I BROUGHT YOU INTO THIS WORLD, AND I'LL TAKE YOU OUT!"

Thursday, September 25, 2008
#6: "I DECLARE BANKRUPTCY!"

Typical Michael Scott.
Organizing a charity run for rabies after hitting someone with your car?
Typical Michael Scott.
Michael declares bankruptcy:
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
#7: "SUIT UP!"

Of all the characters on my list, he may very well be the most fleshed out character. Every detail of Barney is so well thought out, it's *awesome*. Oh, and don't forget the *awesome*, *legendary* Barney catchphrases...
The bracket...
Tuesday, September 23, 2008
#8: "OY WITH THE POODLES ALREADY!"

"Give me a burger, onion rings, and a list of people who killed their parents and got away with it. I need some heroes."
"I'm going to make out in the coatroom. Don't eat my chicken."
Monday, September 22, 2008
#9: "YOU KNOW I ALWAYS WANTED TO PRETEND I WAS AN ARCHITECT..."

of Seinfeld
George is...well, rather pathetic. And he knows it. He embraces it. He lives his life around that fact.
CLASSIC GEORGE MOMENTS:
The Opposite
Sunday, September 21, 2008
#10: "GET OUT OF THE CITY!"
Balki Bartokomous, a shepherd from the fict
ional island of Mypos, came to America to find his cousin, Larry. Balki was refreshingly naive and optimistic, and a just plain 100% good guy with a 100% good heart - the kind of character rarely seen on tv - or in real life.
His misinterpretation of American slang - and the English language in general - his wacky Myposian customs, and his enthusiasm in going along with cousin Larry's ill-conceived schemes made for much hilarity, consistent throughout the series.
Friday, September 19, 2008
Kicking off my favorite tv characters...
Character #1
"Of all the Basic Applied Economic Principles of Capitalism in the Post-Industrial Era Seminars in the world, you had to walk into mine."
"People who have money don't need people."
Character #2
"You'll have to excuse my mother. She suffered a slight stroke a few years ago which rendered her totally annoying. "
"Get back here, you deceitful little Sicilian gekko!"
Character #3
"Momma told me never to do the dance of joy alone, or I would go blind."
"Well, feed me garlic and call me stinky!"
Character #4
"You may look around, and see two groups here. White collar, blue collar. But I don't see it that way. You know why not? Because I am collar-blind."
"That's what she said!"
Character #5
"Give me a burger, onion rings, and a list of people who killed their parents and got away with it. I need some heroes."
"I'm going to make out in the coatroom. Don't eat my chicken."
Character #6
"Yes, you can give him a message. You do take shorthand, don't you? Good, we take it in the South too. Anyway, just tell him that I have been a Southerner all my life, and I can vouch for the fact the we do eat a lot of things down here... and we've certainly all had our share of grits and biscuits and gravy, and I myself have probably eaten enough fried chicken to feed a third world country - not to mention barbecue, cornbread, watermelon, fried pies, okra, and... yes... if I were being perfectly candid, I would have to admit we have also eaten our share of crow, and for all I know - during the darkest, leanest years of the Civil War, some of us may have had a Yankee or two for breakfast. But... speaking for myself and hundreds of thousands of my Southern ancestors who have evolved through many decades of poverty, strife, and turmoil, I would like for Mr. Weaks to know that we have surely eaten many things in the past, and we will surely eat many things in the future, but - God as my witness - we have never, I repeat, never eaten dirt!"
"I think you should tell them to take their invitation, fold it in five corners, and stick it where the sun don't shine."
Character #7
"Do you ever get down on your knees and thank God you know me and have access to my dementia?"
"You know I always wanted to pretend I was an architect. "
Character #8
"It's gonna be legend-... wait for it... and I hope you're not lactose intolerant because the second half of that word is DAIRY!"
"Suit up!"
Character #9
"Shut up! If I want you to speak, I'll wave a Snausage in front of your nose."
"Tragedy blows through your life like a tornado, uprooting everything. Creating chaos. You wait for the dust to settle and then you choose. You can live in the wreckage and pretend it's still the mansion you remember. Or you can crawl from the rubble and slowly rebuild."
Character #10
"...that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard in my life! No wonder you get D's in everything! You're afraid to try because you're afraid your brain is going to explode and it's going to ooze out of your ears. Now I'm telling you, you are going to try as hard as you can. And you're going to do it because I said so. I am your father. I brought you into this world, and I'll take you out!"
"I'm a parent and a taxpayer. And I am probably the only adult who will sue little children."
Sunday, September 14, 2008
BEST TV CHARACTERS EVER...

And, once I have my characters settled upon, I might make a little game out of it. So check back for more info on that!
Friday, September 12, 2008
TOP 5 TV SHOWS GONE TOO SOON...
#5
While this show is kind of...well...a downer, it was well done. Interesting. Intriguing. Somehow addictive. And I was shocked when it was cancelled after 19 episodes. Because it really seemed like the kind of show that would (and should) be around for many seasons. Now, I will admit, no matter how much I liked the show when it came out (I was 16 at the time), when I watch it now (as a 30 year old), I find myself sort of...annoyed by it (Seriously, how many times do they have to say "like" in a scripted show?!?). Perhaps that was the reason for its demise. Too small of a demographic. Still, MSCL deserved more - and, in my opinion, many shows since have "borrowed" (aka ripped off) some of MSCL's greatness and enjoyed far more success. No fair!
It's Like, You Know
1999-2000
I bet none of you have even heard of this show. It was a really cute, witty sitcom in the late 90s starring Jennifer Grey (of Dirty Dancing) as herself. Basically, it was a BIT like a west coast version of Friends or How I Met Your Mother. A group of friends and their day-to-day adventures. I found it to be a bit more clever and fun than a lot of sitcoms out there. Apparently the viewing public (or netword execs, perhaps) did not agree, 'cause ILYK lasted a mere 25 episodes (though I'm not entirely sure all were aired...). The title of the show, by the way, was said in every episode by one of the characters.
Clip time! Warning - I was hesitant to post this clip, because it's a little...well...NOT indicative of the humor and feel of the show. However, it's the only clip on youtube. So, here ya go:
#3
Journeyman
2007/2008
One thing about me, I don't do sci-fi. It's just not me. But I LOVED this show. It lasted a mere 13 episodes, but it was fantastic. Family man/newspaper reporter, Dan Vasser, suddenly begins involuntarily time travelling to help people in trouble. But there's more to it than that - SO much more. It came on after Heroes - and what's insane is that Heroes was getting mad ratings even though it was positively awful (in my opinion) - and Journeyman was getting nothing, though it was actually an excellent show.
#2
Sports Night
1998-2000
GREAT show - great cast, great dialogue, great premise - just GREAT. But it only lasted 2 seasons. The producer (Aaron Sorkin) decided he'd rather devote time to his other show, The West Wing. I love the tagline on imdb.com: "It's about sports...The same way Charlie's Angels was about law enforcement."
The entire first episode :-D
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKaO-hsb3vM&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6mb6awqhQw&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ke_o_SF-H6A&feature=related
#1
Veronica Mars
2004-2007
There's no way I could make this countdown without including my all-time favorite show. VM lasted 3 seasons, but you might as well say it was cancelled after 2 - since the transition from UPN to The CW changed everything. The first 2 seasons were STRONG with excellent mystery arcs spanning the entire season. But once The CW picked it up , they did away with that formula and created merely decent mini-mystery arcs and then a crop of "un-Veronica Marsian" stand-alone episodes. And that just did not work. Another thing that didn't work - the new characters Piz and Parker as well as the exclusion of beloved originals like Wallace and Weevil. Oh, don't get me started on that. Season 3 COULD have been great, had it followed in the footsteps of seasons 1 and 2. But The CW made too many ill-advised changes and ruined an otherwise superb show. Not to say that season 3 wasn't good - it just wasn't the magic that seasons 1 and 2 were. SO, because of the lame meddling from The CW, Veronica Mars died an early death.
ABOUT ME
- Emmalee
- I'm a stay at home mom who homeschools my 2 stay at home daughters. Life is what we make it - and we choose to make it a wonderful, creative, magical adventure each and every day!









